Words have power. They have more power than what we’re willing to admit sometimes. They can tear down walls or build them up. Words can be the gavel of our lives and imprison us, preventing us from pursuing more because we’re trapped in a mindset of “I can’t.” Nonverbal cues also have power. What we communicate when we don’t do something has potential to speak louder than when we put action to our thoughts. Whether it’s our words, actions, or inactions, what we communicate to others has the potential to change the course of history.
When I was a junior and senior in high school, I had an English teacher who had extremely high standards for us as students. She never actually told us that, but she communicated that somehow, and we all just knew it. As students in her class, we knew not to turn in essays that we haphazardly threw together. We painstakingly made sure every comma was in its correct place, every word usage was carefully thought out, and every paragraph was purposeful and succinct. Without my knowing it, Mrs. Beach believed I COULD do the work she assigned, so she pushed me to not just do my work, but to do it well. What she communicated to me helped shape the course of my life. Because she believed I could do things well, I did it. I ended up going to college without too much fear of failure because of the confidence she instilled in me with her high standards.
I’ve thought about this a lot lately as I’ve thought about what I’ve communicated to the kids I’ve taught. When I keep my standards high, I communicate to them, all of them, that I believe they are capable of achieving more than they believe is possible. When I over-scaffold, or “dumb down,” the content I teach, then I am communicating to them that I don’t believe it’s possible for them to achieve more, that they are only capable of achieving the bare minimum.
As I have thought about this more lately, I have come to this conclusion: I don’t have the right to communicate to kids that they can’t do something. When I do, it means that I have decided FOR them that they are not capable of more. When I throw out parts of a curriculum that I have decided are too difficult for my students, then I have decided for them that they are incapable. I never even allow them the chance to productively struggle through something, think their way out of problems, come up with new ideas, or learn from their failures.
I think back to my years in Mrs. Beach’s class. How many times did I have to rewrite essays or reread texts because I wanted to make sure everything I turned in was suitable for her perusal? It wasn’t easy, I definitely struggled, but I learned a great deal through that process. She allowed me to struggle; therefore, she allowed me to learn.
When I communicate that students can’t, then I am deciding their future. Not every student I teach will go to college, and not every student I teach will have a career, but that should be their choice, not mine. Every student who enters my classroom should be held to high standards regardless of what their prior-year’s LEAP score was, where they live, where they go to school, what their skin color is, how much money their parents have, or what I believe about them in general. When I change what I teach based on any of those factors, then I am deciding for them what they will become, and that’s not fair. That’s not my decision to make.
There is power in what we communicate to others. Abusing that power is dangerous, and as a teacher, as a human being, I am obligated to use that power to positively influence and impact the next generation of adults, not hinder them from becoming more simply because of a belief I have.